Best Pizza in Scarsdale

Fresh Italian Pizzas and Pastas Made Just for You

Featured

Discover Pizza One in Scarsdale

Pizza One is your go-to spot in Scarsdale, NY for Italian-inspired meals. We make classic New York–style pizzas, specialty pies, homemade pastas, calzones, salads, subs, and sides like garlic knots and soups. You can enjoy your meal at our casual spot, order for takeout, get it delivered, or plan catering for your events. We make it easy to enjoy great food, your way.

Get Directions

Fresh and Local Ingredients Daily

Our dough is made fresh daily with a signature recipe. We use high-quality ingredients, including locally sourced vegetables whenever possible. Each pizza and pasta dish is made by hand, ensuring every meal meets our high standards. From classic slices to gourmet specialty pies, our menu has something for everyone.

Convenient Ways to Enjoy Our Food

Pizza One is built for convenience. You can dine in for a quick meal or a family gathering, order takeout when you’re on the go, or get delivery straight to your door. Planning a party or work event? Our catering menu is easy to order, and we make sure every dish is ready to enjoy. No matter how you order, Pizza One is ready to serve.

Order Now

Our Fresh Plates

Check out our gallery to see the fresh, hand-crafted meals we make every day. Each photo highlights the quality and care in every dish, ready to enjoy for lunch, dinner, or special gatherings.

Catering for Events

Hosting a party, family gathering, or work event? Pizza One offers catering that fits your needs. With a variety of pizzas, pastas, subs, and sides, our catering menu is designed to please large groups. Ordering is simple, so you can focus on your guests while we take care of the food.

Order Catering

Relax in Our Casual Spot

We want every visit to feel easy and relaxed. Our casual setting makes it simple to grab a slice on your lunch break, enjoy a dinner with family, or host a small event. Friendly staff and a welcoming environment make Pizza One more than just a place to eat—it’s a part of your neighborhood.

Stop by Pizza One Today📍

Pizza One is open every day from 10 AM to 10 PM. Come to 365 Central Park Avenue in Scarsdale, NY, enjoy a fresh pizza, try one of our pasta dishes, or grab a quick slice to go. Whether you dine in, take out, or get delivery, Pizza One makes enjoying Italian-inspired food easy and convenient.

What our guests are saying

Pizza is simply great. Staff was friendly and had many other things beside pizza like ice cream, desserts, and bread. Looks very nice inside and outside. Also has a great variation of pizza (about 20 different types). Very bright inside, even in the night! Would highly reccomend to all pizza lovers!!! 🍕🍦🧁😊

George G.

My husband and I don't always agree about what type of pizza to get but we do agree about what makes a great pizza. He is from here and I'm from LI, and for the 20 years I've lived in Scarsdale, I just haven't found a pizza place in driveable distance that has flavorful sauce, the right crust, and quality cheese... until Pizza One. We both really enjoy their pies: plain, gourmet, and grandma. Their pinwheels, garlic knots, salads, and cheesecakes have all been enjoyable as well. Want a comfy lunch joint with internet? They have that too. I really expected them to be much busier by now. Hoping they grow their business so I can keep my favorite new pizzeria around!

Jennifer S.

I have seen many social media posts about Pizza One on Central Ave and had to try! So yummy!!! And everyone is so nice! A++++++++ Hot honey pepperoni, strawberry gelato, iced coffee and garlic knots.